Upper East Side Jeweler First To Finalize Home Purchase At Surrey Hotel Condo

Crain’s New York Business – 4th September 2025

A low-profile project from the tight-lipped but ambitiously expanding luxury developer Reuben Bros. has officially opened.  The project is the condo portion of the Surrey Hotel, a collection of homes inside the top six floors of the historic 16-story lodging on East 76th Street on the Upper East Side.

The development, which was first shopped around as a private “whisper listing” in June 2024, has now scored its first closing, a nearly 3,000-square-foot unit on the 11th floor, according to a deed that appeared Wednesday in the city register. Its sale price was $15 million.  Sporting a 555-square-foot corner great room with four windows, a kitchen with a wine refrigerator and a primary suite with a home office and two walk-in closets, the three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath home was purchased by jewelry company owner Toni Goutal, the register shows.

Goutal, who is relocating from a prewar co-op on nearby Park Avenue, went into contract on the apartment on July 2, 2024 but didn’t close until Aug. 26 of this year. Though the lag time may seem long, delays of that length are typical with new construction projects, as city officials need to certify them as habitable before buyers can move in.  The Surrey’s offering plan originally called for 14 units to be sold for $214 million overall. But three buyers, who won’t be known until their deals close, combined units to make larger homes, reducing the unit count to 11.

All are in contact except for a 5,200-square-foot penthouse asking $50 million, according to brokers with the project.  Goutal’s 10-year-old business, which makes Victorian-style necklaces adorned with crescent moons, is a partnership with her daughter Chloe. But hotels are in the family’s blood.  Milton Kramer, Goutal’s grandfather, owned the Art Deco Hotel Edison on West 47th Street in Times Square in the mid-20th century, and Goutal’s father, Irwin Kramer, was once an employee of the property, according to his obituary. He later went on to become a managing director of the investment bank Allen & Co.  Meanwhile Goutal’s mother, Terry Kramer, who died in 2019, was a Broadway producer and winner of five Tony Awards, including for “La Cage aux Folles” and “Kinky Boots.”

Founded and operated by the billionaire British brothers David and Simon Reuben, Reuben Bros. has been sweeping up New York properties in the last few years after largely bypassing the city previously.  Under the direction of David’s New York-based son Jamie, the development firm has honed in on hospitality sites, including the Surrey, a prewar property once known for long-term-stays by celebrity guests like actress Bette Davis. The company bought the mixed-use site in 2020 for $150 million. After a lengthy renovation, the hotel portion of the property, which has 100 rooms on the floors below the condos, cut its ribbon in October.

Similarly Reuben Bros. this spring opened The Twenty Two, a 9-story, 78-room prewar hotel and member’s club at 16 E. 16th St. near Union Square that was developed in partnership with Michael Chetrit.

Goutal’s company did not respond to an email by press time, and Allison Brustman, the lawyer who represented Goutal at the closing, could not immediately be reached. Marc Palermo, one of the Douglas Elliman agents marketing the condos, had no comment by press time, and an email to Reuben Bros. went unreturned.