Lord Byron’s Scandalous Mayfair Mansion is On Sale For £29.95m

Sunday Times –  10th December 2023

Once home to the poet, 139 Piccadilly is a lavish property now in desperate need of some lavish care and attention

In Georgian London, 139 Piccadilly, a lavish mansion in Mayfair, was the scene of some of the city’s biggest society bashes — and scandals.

Newly married, Lord Byron bought the vast home in 1815 and wrote some of his most famous poems there, including Parisina and The Siege of Corinth, as he tried in vain to put his hedonistic past behind him.

Lord Byron wrote some of his most famous poems while living at the home

Less than a year later the poet, whose daughter Ada was born at the house, was beset by scandal amid persistent rumours of a relationship with Augusta Leigh, his half-sister. His distressed wife, Annabella Milbanke, famously left him by walking down the steps of the house in full public view and into a waiting carriage with the child in her arms.

After this episode Byron fled the country, never to return. He wrote: “The moment that my wife left me, I was assailed by all the falsehoods that malice could invent or slander publish … there was no crime too dark to be attributed to me.”

Before Byron lived there, the mansion, which dates from the mid-18th century, was home to William Douglas, the Duke of Queensberry, who paid for his long-term mistress Kitty Frederick to live two doors down and who would reputedly sit on his balcony sending out servants to fetch him pretty ladies who caught his eye “as a spider will draw flies into his web”.

Slide back and forth to see how Lord Byron’s mansion looks now — and a CGI of how it may look after a multi-million pound neo-Georgian renovation, according to Casa e Progetti, an interior design studio

 

The sitting room with large fireplace

Other owners of this grade II listed home and their visitors over the years make up a who’s who of the aristocracy. After being remodelled and refaced in neoclassical style in 1891, the property was bought by the Baron and Baroness d’Erlanger, French merchant bankers.

The wealthy baroness Catherine d’Erlanger, who had links to the Medici family in Renaissance Italy, established a salon here that hosted poetry readings in the drawing room attended by the likes of the poet WB Yeats, the Duchess of York (later the Queen Mother) and the society photographer Cecil Beaton, who took a portrait of Catherine in the drawing room in 1930.

In recent years, though, the mansion fell into disrepair. In the 1970s, with its 14,624 sq ft of space being considered far too unwieldy for a home, it was repurposed as office space, its grand principal rooms parcelled off into dull boxes with commercial fittings, its damaged high windows and scuffed fireplaces hidden.

One of the bedrooms

The most recent attempt at the reinvention of the house, which is located on the north side of Piccadilly, opposite the Bomber Command Memorial in Green Park, was made by the billionaire Reuben brothers, whose fortune is £24.399 billion, according to The Sunday Times Rich List 2023 (on which they placed fourth).

David and Simon Reuben bought the faded old building in 2011 at the same time as five other grand Piccadilly buildings, stretching to a combined total of 1.3 acres and including the site of the former In and Out Club (the Naval and Military Club, officially), for £130 million

However, while part of this area is now being turned into a five-star hotel complete with a 2,360 sq ft ballroom, while the surrounding backstreets and their commercial spaces are being transformed into a pedestrianised precinct, 139 Piccadilly remains unused and neglected.


The grand staircase

In 2015 the Reubens obtained planning permission from Westminster council to convert the property into a single family dwelling, with approved plans for an eight-bedroom mansion with a swimming pool, sauna, gym, roof terrace and staff quarters. The mansion’s estimated worth was £45 million.

Despite their stated intention to do this still on their website, nothing has happened — maybe because the Reubens are instead concentrating on building the hotel down the road or on their more recent purchase, as part of a consortium, of the Premier League football club Newcastle United.

Now the brothers have put 139 Piccadilly on the market with Wetherell, the upmarket estate agency, for £29.95 million.

So what can be done with it? Like so many other unwieldy and neglected mansions, 139 seems simply too big to be a private home.

 

The library

A report compiled by Casa e Progetti, an interior design studio, on how much it would cost to refurbish and restore the mansion to its former glory, accompanied by a series of striking CGI images, only seems to reinforce this view. The company estimates that refurbishing, fixing and redesigning the home in full would cost £1,000 per square foot, which would bring the total cost to £15.3 million, although it would increase the house’s size to 15,339 square foot and its value up to an estimated £70 million.

And yet, despite the unfavourable maths, Peter Wetherell is still pinning his hopes on it being bought via his agency as a private home. This, he believes, is because of the influx of the “new rich” from the Middle East or tech gurus from the United States who have made their money at lightning pace. He envisages that a buyer would want to set up a home alongside a “private office” to manage their wealth in the same building.

Wetherell compares the new generation of the super-wealthy with the US industrialists who bought trophy homes in Mayfair a century ago.

“If you look back at the gilded age on either side of 1900, those families had inherited their wealth from the Industrial Revolution, then they themselves made a massive amount of money, and they were spending it — they wanted to become the next aristocracy.”


One of the reception rooms

Research shows precisely the extent to which this cohort of young Middle Eastern buyers are transforming the ultra-luxury market in prime London. Beauchamp Estates claims twice as many Mayfair “super-prime” homes (upwards of £10 million) have sold in 2023 so far compared to last year, with sales reaching a combined value of £313 million, almost triple the equivalent value of £123 million in 2022.

And if Wetherell’s gamble doesn’t pay off, and he can’t manage to lure a member of the Qatari royal family to 139 Piccadilly, what on earth can be done with it to stop it from crumbling completely? It could, conceivably, be turned into luxury “lock up-and-leave” flats, somewhat like the Buxmead development on the Bishop’s Avenue in Highgate, north London, which would be more practical than a mansion for most wealthy buyers. A return to its previous life as a dowdy office building is very unlikely, meanwhile, given how expensive it would be to run or occupy in Mayfair.

Byron’s year living in this enormous home was filled with turbulence and strife. Time will tell if it continues to rot or if, in a modern London plot twist, it will be reborn as a haven for the new mega-rich.