The Times – 9th April 2023
The billionaire pair face big hurdles if they want to outflank the favourites in a battle for lucrative media rights
The billionaire Reuben brothers, two of the richest men in Britain, and five rural racecourses are forming an unlikely alliance that could shake up the financing of Irish racing. Arena Racecourse Company (Arc), which is owned by Simon and David Reuben, is in talks to acquire Dundalk racecourse, Ireland’s only all-weather track. It has separately made an offer to buy the broadcast media rights to the five racecourses — Sligo, Roscommon, Kilbeggan, Limerick and Thurles.
A significant hurdle here, however, is that, although the racecourses own the rights to transmit images from their property, they cannot sell them. Under statute, the media rights committee of Horse Racing Ireland (HRI), the sport’s governing body, is the sole agent mandated to negotiate the sale of those rights. And that committee is finalising an agreement with Sports Information Services (SIS), the supplier of racing images to bookmakers in Ireland and Britain, and Racecourse Media Group (RMG), owner of Racing TV, to cover all 26 race tracks on the island.
The SIS and RMG offer is expected to be circulated shortly to all 26 members of the Association of Irish Racecourses (AIR). A meeting will be then called to approve the proposals. SIS/RMG, which currently holds the rights under a deal negotiated in 2016, is said to be offering up to €47 million a year. The five tracks approached by Arc, which form United Irish Racecourses (UIR), are opposed to the deal. Linking payment to a number of parameters including betting turnover, it says the deal favours larger racecourses, which host bigger meetings.
It is also unhappy at the estimated €7 million per annum to be paid to HRI for data rights, effectively race cards. It believes the payment is excessive, up to seven times more than the equivalent in the UK, and eats into the racecourses’ share of the total rights pot. HRI also owns and operates four racecourses, Leopardstown, Fairyhouse, Navan and Tipperary and has a stake in the Curragh. It owns Cork, which is leased to an independent operator. It is by far the biggest racecourse owner in the country and so the largest beneficiary of the rights deal.
HRI insists that data rights income is invested back into upgrading venues. However, UIR claims that the biggest beneficiaries are the largest tracks and not the small rural ones. Between 2015 and 2020, Tipperary and Kilbeggan received €8,000 and €128,000 respectively from HRI, compared to the €7 million granted to Leopardstown or €12.8 million to the Curragh.
A sense of grievance may offer Arc a foothold in the market. It has reportedly offered the five UIR race courses a guarantee of €100,000 per fixture from Arc, which is substantially more than they would earn under the SIS/RMG deal. Arc is the largest racecourse owner in Britain, with 16 horse racing tracks and five greyhound stadia. It hosts 40 per cent of all race meetings in the UK. It has also formed the Racing Partnership (TRP), with Sky Sports. TRP handles the media and data rights for all 16 Arc venues and a further six independent racecourses in Britain, including Newbury and Ascot. Arc sells the live feeds to bookmakers, in shops and online, and Sky gets the direct to home rights. Its main competitors are the SIS/RMG.
Arc’s interest in Dundalk, which hosts both greyhound and horse racing meetings, is pertinent. Although a small track, Dundalk’s all-weather venue accounts for about ten per cent of all meetings or fixtures. It is also profitable, generating about €3 million in cash each year. Dundalk made €1.6 million from media rights in 2021, but as much as €2.5 million in 2019. In 2021, Dundalk earned €4.1 million out of its total turnover of €4.8 million from commissions on off course betting and media rights. Pre pandemic, it was only taking in €264,000 a year, from admissions. Arc is reported to be offering up to €40 million for the venue, which has been heavily grant aided by HRI. At this time, Dundalk is Ireland’s only all weather track, though Tipperary, owned rather pointedly by HRI, is developing a similar facility.
Increasingly the media rights row is developing into a split between racing’s haves and have nots. It also raises questions over the statutory mandate given to HRI. “In the UK, like-minded racecourses can team together to do their own negotiations, which maximises the income for racecourses,” said Paddy Dunican, secretary of UIR and managing director of Kilbeggan Races.
Paul Hensey, chief executive of AIR, said the hope was still “to bring along” all its 26 members with the SIS/RMG deal. “It is a very, very good deal,” he said, which “reflects well on the quality of the product.” Reports also suggest that it could lead to up to 30 more race meetings being held here, supporting the bloodstock industry.
Hensey said that the terms of the brokered deal were fair and transparent. He added that the selection process was “robust”, from invitation to tender to short list to the choice of preferred bidder, in this case the SIS and RMG consortium. The Arc-backed Racing Partnership is believed to have been an underbidder, and its unsolicited offer to the UIR tracks does look like it is trying to gatecrash the party.
Hensey notes that, although the media rights committee sits within the HRI, it is chaired by the chairman of AIR, Conor O’Neill of Punchestown. As it stands, it seems likely that UIR will reject the current proposals. Others, including Dundalk, may follow. They could then instruct the HRI media rights committee to negotiate a deal with Arc. At the very least, the Arc offer provides them with leverage to increase their cut from the SIS/RMG deal.
“UIR is at present considering all proposals and wants the best financial deal for its racecourses,” Dunican said. This race has some way yet to run.