The Last and Most Expensive Unit at New York’s Surrey Hotel to Ask $50 Million

Wall Street Journal – 4th November 2024

The duplex penthouse is slated to hit the market following a bumpy journey for the newly refurbished, circa-1920s building

On Manhattan’s Upper East Side, a penthouse above the newly refurbished Surrey hotel is slated to come on the market for $50 million.  The listing for the nearly 5,200-square-foot duplex penthouse comes after a roller coaster journey for the storied, nearly century-old building, which was the subject of bankruptcy proceedings at the height of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020.

The circa-1920s hotel was purchased that year for $150 million, 30% less than its asking price, by Reuben Brothers, a family-run investment company with offices in London, Geneva, and Milan. Reuben Brothers is now putting the finishing touches on a three-year renovation project. The hotel, which is now named The Surrey, a Corinthia hotel, reopened in October, while a collection of 14 condo units upstairs is set for completion early next year, according to Jamie Reuben, a scion of the family business.

The hotel was originally built in the 1920s

Reuben Brothers has already signed or issued contracts for the other 13 residences above the hotel without any formal marketing campaign, according to a spokeswoman for the project.  The three-bedroom duplex penthouse is the Surrey’s most expensive unit, and includes three private terraces featuring the building’s original parapets. It has white-oak flooring and custom casement windows designed to reference the hotel’s original 1920s aesthetic. The kitchen has white-oak millwork and a Calacatta Gold marble island.    Residents of the condominium have access to the hotel’s spa and fitness center. They also have priority access to elevators on the ground floor with a key fob, ensuring they get a private elevator with no hotel guests, Reuben said.

 

The three-bedroom penthouse, shown in renderings, is asking $50 million

 The Surrey is located on East 76th Street off Madison Avenue. When it was built, the Surrey, along with the Sherry-Netherland, the Carlyle Hotel and others, drew a number of long-term residents looking for homes with the amenities of a hotel. Among the Surrey’s residents were actresses Ethel Merman and Bette Davis. Just two years after its grand opening, the Surrey was the scene of a high-society tragedy, when two young heirs to the Guggenheim fortune fell from the roof, according to contemporary newspaper reports.

In recent years, the hotel became dated and required upgrades, Reuben said. During the pandemic, Reuben Brothers purchased it out of bankruptcy, part of a strategy to acquire well-located real-estate assets in the U.S. at lower-than-normal prices, he said.  “There were pretty serious questions about whether New York would ever return to being the financial mega-powerhouse it was pre-Covid,” he said of the decision. “It wasn’t something I subscribed to. I always believed it would come back.”

When completed, the penthouse will have access to hotel amenities

While $50 million is a significant sum in the New York market, it doesn’t come close to the asking prices for some of the newly built units on nearby Billionaires’ Row, where apartments are listed for as much as $150 million.  The Manhattan luxury condo market has fluctuated over the past few months, as buyers contend with interest-rate shifts and the presidential election. The number of luxury Manhattan home sales declined by 2.8% in the third quarter, compared with the same period of last year, according to a report by Douglas Elliman. The median sales price also fell by 4%.  Elliman’s new development arm is handling sales at the building.

“I think we’re in a pretty good place,” Reuben said of the market. “It’s not the best it’s been, and definitely not the worst it’s been. For the right product and the right location, there are buyers.”